Vegan Burger vs Beef Burger
Vegetable or “veggie” burgers have grown ubiquitous as meat substitutes, appearing on restaurant and fast food menus alongside hamburgers. They're no longer just for people who eat a vegetarian or vegan diet. When picking between vegetable and beef burgers, you need to make an informed decision.
What Is A Vegan Burger?
A vegan burger is a patty made entirely from plant-based ingredients. The food doesn't contain animal products of any kind. In fact, the two main ingredients in vegan burger patties are soy and pea protein, making them meat-like. It's easy to judge a vegan burger by its appearance. Whether the patty has a reddish hue from the soy-based protein or if it's uniform in colour, it usually means that it's a vegan burger.
The second important thing to look for in a vegan burger is its texture. A vegan burger is a meat substitute, like tofu and seitan, that tastes like meat but doesn't contain meat. It's always made from wheat protein, not dairy or eggs. When you order one, you're not eating meat. You're eating a ground beef patty. Some veggie burgers use wheat, and some veggie burgers use soy. Some veggie burgers come in a hamburger bun or on a bunless bun.
A vegan burger is made of a primarily plant-based patty, made from a blend of mushrooms, vegetables, and grains that are seasoned and cooked to cook to a texture similar to a beef patty. They are often used instead of a meat-based burger, especially in vegetarian or vegan restaurants. But they're not vegetarian or vegan-friendly or a meat substitute and the only vegan version I've seen anywhere is Impossible Burger.
Vegan burgers, also known as vegetable patties or veggie burgers, are a popular vegetarian or vegan substitute for burgers made from textured soy protein (also called textured vegetable protein or TVP). They're usually made with the same mix of wheat gluten, soy protein, and vegetable oil that a standard burger is made with. The result is a burger with the same structure and consistency as meat but the nutritional content and texture of vegetables.
Typically, a “vegan burger” is not made from a substitute for animal-based protein but rather a vegetable-based patty made from wheat protein, soy protein, vegetable protein, gluten and/or potato starch. In the United States, most veggie burgers are created by adding a mix of other ingredients to a patty to change its texture, taste, or colour. For example, to make a beef burger, many manufacturers add beef to a batter made with egg and rice flour to create a burger patty cooked in a patty grill.
By comparison, a vegan “burger” is made from a similar mix of ingredients, but instead of beef or poultry, it substitutes a non-dairy ingredient. If you're not familiar with the term “vegan burger,” this burger is typically made of beans or grains, vegetable protein, and sometimes vegetable oil or coconut oil.
You won't find eggs, dairy, or other meat products in this “burger,” and its ingredient list will be short. Since most veggie burgers are relatively small, they're often referred to as mini burgers. If that sounds familiar, it's likely because they have recently emerged in the trend of so-called “luxe” burgers, with names like “Gluten-Free Acme” or “Gluten-Free Mad Cow.”
What Is A Beef Burger?
“Beefburger” is a generic term for the two major meat substitutes on the market: soy and wheat, though other animal proteins are also used. The beef burger is the classic American burger, commonly associated with the hamburger bun and beef patty. A beef burger has beef and contains beef as the primary ingredient. A vegetarian patty would contain vegetables as the primary ingredient, which will change the taste and texture.
The same is true for veggie burgers. A beef burger is the same as a ground beef patty, but with beef. When you order one, you're eating ground beef, not ground wheat. These meat-filled burgers are generally larger than the standard veggie burger, measuring between 8 ounces and 11 ounces, and often with toppings like bacon, cheddar cheese, and other premium additions. If you haven't heard of beef burgers, this variety of burgers has been around since the early 19th century, when cows were the source of meat on the streets of US cities.
Until then, Europeans only ate what they could forage. The first commercial beef burgers were made in the US by chewing up leftover beef scraps (butchers rarely chopped up whole cows). They were not much more than thinly-sliced, lean, cubed pieces of meat. Beef burgers could be eaten out of hand or purchased in a “pounder.” The main use was to feed voracious lions in zoos and circuses.
Beef burgers are usually made from ground beef, so the texture of these burgers will be quite similar to those you find in grocery stores. Beef burgers are often seasoned with salt, pepper, chilli powder and cumin, giving them a flavour to keep the bun sizzling on the grill. A beef burger is a protein-filled hamburger patty made from beef, bread crumbs, and other seasonings.
Some beef burgers use mechanically separated or “grilled” beef, but this meat should not be confused with real ground beef. Ground meat is usually dehydrated for easy handling. Many varieties of beef burgers use sodium and processed additives to achieve flavour. Although these may improve the overall appearance of the burger, it is the fat and protein that should be the focus of the recipe.
Beef burgers are made from ground beef or minced beef, seasoned with salt, pepper, sugar, pepperoncini, garlic powder, and onion powder. They can be prepared with or without added preservatives and often contain tomato paste, garlic, and spices. Beef burgers are usually available during the summer when eating out on the town is more appealing than snuggling under a blanket with a book or iPad because of the seasonality of beef.
Beef burgers are usually ground beef seasoned with salt, pepper, sugar, pepperoncini, garlic powder, and onion powder. They can be prepared with or without added preservatives and often contain tomato paste, garlic, and spices.
Health Benefits Of Vegan Burgers
Health benefits associated with a vegan diet, including fewer cancer and heart disease cases, have driven meat-free options into the mainstream. Because meat and dairy production requires massive quantities of natural resources, it is only a matter of time before we see a movement to “plant-based” diets.
In a blog post titled “Terrific New Research Indicates Eating Meat Has Serious Health Consequences” published by Jessica Almy, a spokesperson for the Humane Research Council, she writes that “scientists from Tufts, Dartmouth, and Harvard found that reducing meat and dairy is associated with saving money, and cutting animal products is associated with other health benefits including improving longevity.
They're a source of protein, which is known to increase muscle strength and endurance. Although a few reports have surfaced on the harmful side effects of certain vegan foods, the meat alternatives are considered safe. You can eat them with no concerns.
They're full of heart-healthy foods such as plant-based proteins and antioxidants. Compared to most meat-based products, consuming vegan foods such as these is recommended to lower the risk of diabetes, heart disease and cancer. They're loaded with nutrients that are important for your overall health. With no cholesterol, saturated fat and trans fat in them, you're getting a wide variety of vitamins and nutrients.
You also get iron, zinc, potassium, selenium, vitamin B12, protein and other essential nutrients. People who eat a plant-based diet have lower blood pressure and cholesterol than those who eat a normal diet. In a vegan diet, no meat is consumed. That means fewer calories. As a result, plant-based burgers have a much lower calorie content than beef burgers. Vegan burgers are also more nutritious. They contain more protein and fibre than beef burgers and contain higher key vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, and more.
When made from beans, potatoes, or peas, a vegan burger typically contains fewer calories and more fibre and protein than the equivalent ground beef burger and the latter's low-calorie content. They are also lower in cholesterol and saturated fat. Plant-based burgers are a nutritional improvement over meat burgers for people concerned about their cholesterol or who want to reduce it.
As with beef burgers, vegan burger makers use different blends of textured vegetable protein to achieve the texture and consistency of ground beef. Some rely on soybean and textured vegetable proteins or exclude them altogether. One of the most popular soybean-based meat substitutes is Tofurky, which is vegan and high in protein and fibre.
Health Benefits Of Beef Burgers
Beef, lamb and other fatty, semi-dry red meats may make you feel full for longer, are better for heart health, and help you control weight. They are also the most affordable meats and the most common. Vegans tend to view meat as unhealthy, and some claim they'll do better eating vegetables. But studies on vegetarian diets fail to show that they're healthier than omnivorous diets.
Still, vegetarians who choose meat burgers tend to be healthy, according to Dr. Jeffrey D. Smith, a leading nutritional biologist at Rutgers University. For one thing, they choose leaner cuts, such as ground beef, compared to ground pork, the most common meat replacement. Most vegetarian burgers contain at least 30% or more pork fat, which isn't good for weight control. One of the main reasons people choose to eat a beef burger over a veggie burger is health.
Beef burgers are often higher in iron and B12 and lower in calories, sodium and fat. The more health-conscious you are, the more likely you are to choose beef over veggie burgers. In fact, because of their health benefits, people on diets should make beef burgers their preferred meat alternative.
Beef burgers offer a nutritious source of protein. A 20-ounce serving of ground beef provides 4 grams of complete protein, a type of protein that is both digestible and will help promote the growth of lean tissue in your body. It also contains more than half your daily iron needs and contains more than 20 essential nutrients such as B-vitamins, protein, and some trace minerals.
Beef contains high levels of iron and B12, both of which are essential for strong blood cells. The cholesterol levels in beef burgers are low (between 50 and 60 mg per hamburger), while their saturated fat content is usually less than five grams. But the higher saturated fat content does not increase the amount of cholesterol. In fact, in many American diets, it's likely low or nonexistent.
A 2016 study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association showed that the increasing amount of beef Americans are eating can be credited to economic reasons. In Europe, which has fewer opportunities for beef producers, high levels of saturated fat don't often impact a person's cholesterol levels. So as Americans increasingly adopt vegetarian and vegan diets, beef consumption continues to increase.
Nutrition In Vegan Burgers
One patty has 4 grams of protein, 6 grams of fibre, and 29 grams of fat. Compared to beef burgers, it contains significantly less saturated fat and more vitamins and minerals. If you enjoy the taste of beef and want to maximize its nutrient profile, vegan burgers have you covered.
The nutritional value of a vegan burger is comparable to that of ground beef. Plant-based burgers provide comparable amounts of calories (250-280 calories) and high-quality protein to traditional ground beef (20 percent fat or more) (20 grams per patty). Ingredients in vegetarian and vegan burgers vary, and you can use them to build a burger or a veggie burger. So you don't have to guess at nutrition.
Many vegan burgers are extremely lean. Because of this, many have high levels of Vitamin A and C. Vitamin A in a burger provides strong immune support and is an anti-inflammatory. Vitamin C provides strong collagen production and aids with wound healing.
Because vegan burgers contain fewer calories than most meat burgers, they're a good choice if you're a dieter or a health-conscious individual. They're also filling, especially if you eat the bun and sides along with the burger. However, vegetarian burgers can also be higher in sodium than other burgers, which can concern those with high blood pressure or other health conditions.
Vegetarian and vegan burgers are generally made from seitan or other plant-based protein. These burgers can be relatively low in calories. However, they have less protein and fat than meat burgers, and many recipes don't have much flavour. Because of this, it's best to be mindful of calories, macros, and especially protein content if you're trying to eat healthily and still enjoy burgers.
Vegan burgers are generally healthy and have plenty of good fats. They contain high amounts of fibre, magnesium, vitamin B6, potassium, protein, healthy fat, phytonutrients and beta carotene. Many vegan burgers are often higher in protein than traditional veggie burgers because they use tofu, quinoa and potato protein.
Nutrition In Beef Burger
It's no secret that a hamburger patty is a delectable, meaty staple of a summertime barbeque. Beef is an excellent source of protein, iron, and B vitamins. Even better, it contains a vast array of anti-inflammatory nutrients, including vitamin B12 and iron. And it's rich in several micronutrients, including zinc, selenium, vitamin B6, potassium, copper, and manganese. But those nutrients are lost when you cook beef.
Even though they might have more calories, beef burgers have more protein and iron than vegetables while packing more potassium, calcium and vitamin C. Meanwhile, vegetable burgers tend to be lower in fat and calories. You'll get roughly 225 calories, 12 grams of fat, 5 grams of saturated fat, and 27 grams of protein from a 4-ounce cooked lean beef burger. It's a decent source of vitamin B6, iron, and phosphorus, as well as an exceptional source of niacin, vitamin B12, zinc, and selenium.
Beef burgers also have a higher amount of carbohydrates than vegetarian burgers. The beef industry is big, so, naturally, the meat industry has produced plant-based “beef” patties as an alternative to real beef. According to the USDA, each ounce of beef provides about 3 calories and about 23 grams of protein (nearly all of which is from the muscles, not the fat).
A single vegetarian or vegan burger serving has almost all of the protein of a beef burger, but it has less fat and fewer carbohydrates. While a serving of beef burgers has 5 grams of protein, a serving of a veggie burger has 4 grams of protein. In terms of overall nutrition, beef burgers are more “complete.”
They contain more protein, calcium, iron, and other essential nutrients like zinc, vitamin B12, vitamin D, fibre, thiamin, niacin, thiamine, and riboflavin. In comparison, vegetables are not necessarily “complete” and are lower in protein, calories, fat, and fibre.
Eating a beef burger will get you close to the recommended daily intake of protein. Looking at the nutritional numbers of beef burgers, it's hard to imagine that the energy in one is greater than that of a single serving of vegetables. However, they have higher amounts of protein and micronutrients, which provides their superiority.
Core Difference Between Vegan Burgers And Beef Burgers
Most vegan burgers have an integrated textured vegetable patty. These patties contain large pieces of vegetables, usually root vegetables such as carrots and sweet potatoes, and have been flattened. While the textured vegetable patties look similar to a beef patty, they don't contain any lean meat. When you add vegan cheese or a patty containing just egg whites for dairy-free cooking, these veggie burgers resemble ground beef burgers in texture.
The texture and flavour difference between the veggie burger and the beef patty is huge. The texture is softer and creamier. The flavour is milder. With an egg-free patty, the flavour will depend on the flavour of your desired toppings. This distinction is the difference between eating a veggie burger versus a meat patty.
A vegan burger patty is made from a mixture of wheat flour, water, and soy protein, while a beef patty uses flour, water, salt and sugar. The breading consists of potato flour, black pepper, onions, garlic, olive oil, and spices in both cases. The only difference between a beef burger and a vegetarian burger is the texture, which is usually firmer and drier. It is processed shelf-stable meat.
Similarities Of Vegan Burgers And Beef Burgers
Vegetable burgers do have a similar texture to beef burgers. One might not notice the difference in the colour of the patty, but the texture and even heat may be different. Vegetable burgers often have more water and solids, while beef burgers have a drier texture, so the texture might better indicate how these two burgers compare.
Vegan burgers often have a nice, soft, juicy texture. Vegan burgers have a slightly different taste than beef burgers because the burger patty is made from different plants and grains. Vegan burgers are usually made from legumes or pulses. These often include peas, chickpeas, lentils, and soybean. Both vegan and beef burgers have large patties with exposed or semi-cooked surfaces.
Which Is Healthier?
Meat, poultry, and fish burgers have been labelled “lean” and “red” for decades, indicating lean protein and fat percentage in the burger. “Vegetarian” is generally used to describe any burger made from plant-based ingredients. However, most are still made with vegetable oil, and some can contain eggs and/or dairy.
Using the term “vegan” can be confusing for some. The term is not a health warning; it's merely an indication of a dish's lack of animal products. A more detailed look at this comparison (with sources) can be found on the U.S. Department of Agriculture website. Vegan Burger contains substantially fewer calories. Veggie Burgers have been shown to reduce your risk of developing Type 2 Diabetes, heart disease and even certain types of cancer.
Because there are so many sources for quality information on which hamburger is best for you, deciding which one is right for you depends on your own preferences. So, which is better: a vegan or a beef burger? The answer depends on your dietary needs, whether or not you're vegetarian or vegan, and how many burgers you plan on eating per week.
Vegetarian or vegan burgers are an excellent choice. You're still eating good, nutritious food, but in a more efficient and balanced way. However, they're not the only choice, so it's important to make an informed decision about the burgers you eat and how you will eat them.
I trust you enjoyed reading the article about Vegan Burger vs Beef Burger. Please stay tuned. There are more blog posts to come very shortly.
Your Opinion Is Important To Me
Ideas? Thoughts? Questions? I would love to hear from you. Would you mind leaving me your questions, experience and remarks about Vegan Burger vs Beef Burger in the comments section below? You can also reach me by email at Jeannette@LivingTheVeganLifestyle.org.